| Player Name | Rounds |
| Hughes, Les | 28 |
| Huemmer, Keith | 26 |
| Kouse, Mike | 24 |
| Sothard, Fred | 22 |
| McKenzie, Jim | 22 |
| Jacobs, Steve | 21 |
| Turney, Joe | 19 |
| Swann, Bill | 18 |
| Daniels, Ollie | 18 |
| Zimmer, Doug | 17 |
| Kite, Kevin | 15 |
| Shumaker, Emery | 15 |
| McDonald, Mark | 14 |
| Perkins, Tony | 13 |
| Lyons, Rick | 12 |
| Finley, Preston | 11 |
| Portz, Greer | 10 |
| Stant, Gary | 8 |
| Delaney, Pat | 8 |
| Lotton, Jim | 7 |
| Lyons, Connor | 5 |
| Lyons, Evan | 5 |
| Jenness, Rob | 4 |
| Beacom, Cody | 4 |
| Clevenger, Scott | 3 |
| Delk, Curt | 3 |
| Shoemaker, Ian | 2 |
| Williams, Matt | 2 |
| Hawkins, Don | 2 |
| Stephenson, Dylan | 2 |
| Shumaker, Tyler | 2 |
| Manning, Hope | 1 |
| Hotaling, Rory | 1 |
| Brooks, Rick | 1 |
| Portz, Clay | 1 |
| Alhasan, Tareq | 1 |
| Kress, Tim | 1 |
| Petticrew, Steve | 1 |
| Ferguson, Tom | 1 |
| Sine, Josh | 1 |
| Thurman, Jeff | 1 |
| Manning, Tim | 1 |
| Petticrew, Zach | 1 |
| Stanley, Terry | 1 |
